Skip to main content
Free 20-minute marketing audit
Limited spots available

Have a question?

We usually reply within 5 minutes.

WWhatsApp TTelegram

Where Procurement Kickbacks Hide and How to Control Them in Uzbekistan

How to control procurement kickbacks and inflated supplier prices: three-quote rule, price history, dual approval, limits, red flags and a fair conversation.

Where Procurement Kickbacks Hide and How to Control Them in Uzbekistan

The market price of cement has not changed. Yet on your delivery notes it rises a little every month. Same supplier, same buyer. Nobody says anything, because each difference is small. By year end, those differences add up to real money.

If you run a company in Uzbekistan, especially one managed remotely or through a local team, this pattern is easy to miss. This article explains how procurement kickbacks work and how to control them without heavy bureaucracy. You will get a price history template, the three-quote rule, dual approval, spending limits and a fair way to talk to an employee.

The topic is part of financial discipline for a business. Discipline plans where the money goes. Procurement control makes sure it goes out at the right price.

How a kickback works and why it is hard to see

A kickback is a hidden share that a supplier pays to the employee who decides on a purchase. In return, the employee chooses that supplier and asks no questions. The supplier does not pay this from its own margin. The amount is built into the price, and in the end you pay it.

It is hard to see because every single purchase looks normal. The paperwork is correct, the goods arrived, the invoice is there. The problem shows up not in one purchase but across a series of them.

Kickbacks usually take one of four forms:

  • Price mark-up — How it works: Price slightly above market, the difference is shared; How it shows: Price history rises faster than the market
  • Lower-grade goods — How it works: Same price, cheaper grade delivered; How it shows: Defects, returns, complaints from production
  • Short delivery — How it works: 100 bags on paper, fewer in reality; How it shows: Recounts at receiving do not match
  • "Only possible" supplier — How it works: Competitors are excluded on various pretexts; How it shows: The same supplier for years, no alternatives

A kickback is not always cash. It can be a gift, a "holiday trip" or a job for the employee's relative. The essence is the same: the decision serves personal gain, not the company.

Other types of staff theft, such as cash, stock or fuel, are a separate topic covered in how to prevent employee theft. This article focuses only on purchasing.

A real-life scenario: a canteen and a meat supplier

This is a hypothetical example. Imagine you own a 120-seat canteen in Tashkent. For two years you have bought meat from one supplier. A purchasing officer handles orders, and you see only the monthly total.

Also read Product Certification in Uzbekistan: Which Goods Need What, Recognition of Foreign Certificates and Digital Marking Business · 10 min

One day an acquaintance mentions buying the same meat cheaper elsewhere. For three weeks you note market prices. The difference per kilogram is modest. But the canteen uses several tonnes of meat a month.

Then you pull the price history. It turns out the supplier raised the price each time, saying "the market went up". The market sometimes went down, but your price never did. This is not proof of a kickback. It is a good enough reason to ask questions.

Is there an item like this in your business? When did you last compare its price with the market?

Bakery owner compares flour delivery notes side by side with her bookkeeper

Price history: the foundation of control

Control starts with a price history. A price history is a simple table showing when, from whom and at what price each key item was bought. A spreadsheet is enough.

Include at least these columns:

  • Date — What to record: Purchase date
  • Item — What to record: Name, grade, unit of measure
  • Supplier — What to record: Who it was bought from
  • Price — What to record: Price per unit
  • Market price — What to record: Price checked this week, and the source
  • Variance — What to record: How far your price differs from the market, in percent
  • Buyer — What to record: Responsible employee

You do not need to track everything. Pick the 15 to 20 items that make up most of your purchasing spend. A large share of spend usually sits in a few items, and that is where kickbacks tend to be.

Who checks the market price? Not the person who buys. That is a job for the accountant, the general manager or you. Once a month, call around about 3 to 5 items, visit a market or check public listings. It takes an hour or two.

Three quotes, dual approval and limits

Price history shows the past. Future purchases need rules.

The three-quote rule. A commercial quote is a supplier's formal offer with price, terms and delivery time. For any purchase above a set amount, collect at least three written quotes. One of them must come from a new supplier you have not worked with before. Otherwise, all three may come from "friendly" companies that coordinate with each other.

Dual approval. One person requests the purchase, another approves it. The buyer proposes a supplier, but the final decision belongs to the general manager or the owner. In a small business, the second signature is often the owner's.

Limits. You will not have time to approve everything. Set three tiers by amount:

  1. Small purchase: the employee buys and only records it in the price history.
  2. Medium purchase: dual approval required.
  3. Large purchase or new supplier: three quotes plus dual approval.

Set the amounts to fit your business. What matters is that limits are written down and everyone knows them.

One more control: separate ordering from receiving. The person who placed the order should not be the one who accepts and counts the goods. That makes short delivery or grade swapping much harder to hide.

Splitting a large purchase into several smaller ones to stay under a limit also happens. So at month end, check the total per supplier as well. Payment order and who approves payments are covered in accounts payable management.

Changing and rotating suppliers

Years with a single supplier create the most comfortable setting for a kickback. That does not make the supplier bad. Without competition, prices simply drift upward.

Practical rules:

  • keep at least two active suppliers for every key item;
  • once or twice a year, run a tender for key items: request quotes from several suppliers at the same time and pick the best one;
  • if you have several buyers, periodically rotate who handles which suppliers;
  • test a new supplier on a small batch first.

You can keep a good partner too. If their price is competitive in the new round, you now know it from evidence.

Business owner personally checks a valve at a plumbing market to compare prices

Red flags to watch for

A red flag is not guilt in itself. It is a reason to look closer, and it points to the process, not the person:

  • one supplier's price is always above market, yet nobody replaces them;
  • the price only goes up and stays there even when the market falls;
  • quotes arrive in the same template with the same typos;
  • the employee rejects other suppliers on various pretexts;
  • purchases are split into amounts just below the limit;
  • the employee never takes leave and never hands purchasing to anyone;
  • quantity or quality discrepancies at receiving keep repeating.

One sign proves nothing. When two or three cluster in one place, it is time to dig deeper. An internal audit helps here, because it reviews purchasing regularly and systematically.

If you suspect something: a careful conversation

The biggest mistake is accusing without evidence. If the employee is innocent, you lose a good specialist. If they are guilty, they get time to clean up the paperwork.

The right sequence:

  1. Gather evidence. Price history, market prices, quotes, receiving documents. Everything in writing.
  2. Talk one-on-one. Not in front of the team. Do not accuse, ask: "This item is priced above market. Can you explain why?"
  3. Request a written explanation. Sometimes there is a real reason: deferred payment, quality, delivery terms.
  4. Change the process. Whatever the outcome, introduce dual approval and price history.
  5. Consult a lawyer. Dismissal, recovering losses or any other legal step only after advice from a local lawyer.

Sometimes introducing controls alone brings prices back to market level. If you plan to automate, an ERP procurement module can keep price history and approvals automatically.

A plan for the first month

You do not have to introduce everything in one day. Go step by step:

  1. Week 1. Pick the 15 to 20 items that make up most of your purchasing spend and start the price history table.
  2. Week 2. Independently check the market price of five of them and record the variance.
  3. Week 3. Approve the three-tier limits and the dual approval rule in writing and explain them to staff.
  4. Week 4. For the item with the largest variance, collect three fresh commercial quotes.

After a month you will have a clear picture of your prices. Decisions will rest on numbers, not on gut feeling.

The bottom line: control the process, not the person

A procurement kickback is not one big theft but many small differences. You do not need to be a detective to find it. A price history, independent market checks, three quotes, dual approval and limits are enough.

Start with one step: take the 5 most expensive items you buy and find out their market price this week. No gap means peace of mind. A gap means you now know where to start.

Frequently asked questions

What is a procurement kickback?

A kickback is a hidden share that a supplier pays to the employee who decides on a purchase. In return, the employee picks that supplier, accepts an inflated price or ignores quality and delivery problems. The company pays in the end, because the kickback is built into the price.

Do I need three quotes for every purchase?

No. For small, recurring purchases, a price history and a spending limit are enough. Apply the three-quote rule to purchases above a set amount and to new suppliers. You set that amount yourself, based on the size of the business.

If I suspect a buyer of taking kickbacks, can I dismiss them right away?

Do not rush. Gather evidence first: price history, market prices, documents. Then hold a one-on-one conversation without accusations and request a written explanation. Before deciding on dismissal or any other legal step in Uzbekistan, consult a local lawyer.

How often should suppliers be rotated?

You do not have to replace everyone. Keep at least two active suppliers for each key item and compare terms again once or twice a year. Keeping a good partner whose price stays competitive is also part of control.

Is this article legal advice?

No. It is a practical management guide. For the legal consequences of kickback cases and the documents involved, consult a local lawyer based on the current legislation published on lex.uz.

Want to see where prices creep up in your Uzbek purchasing?

We can review the price history of your key items together and write approval limits and a dual-signature rule that fit your business.

Discuss purchasing controls →

Let's work out where to start

Free consultation with a DORA specialist

Message on Telegram

Let's discuss your project

Leave your number and a specialist will get in touch.

Send a request via Telegram

Your details are used only to contact you.