Choosing between a global ERP, a local platform such as 1C and a custom system is not about which product is best — it is about which process should live in which tool. For local statutory accounting and tax reporting, an established local platform like 1C is often the pragmatic choice. For a small entity with simple processes, packaged SaaS gets you running quickly. A global ERP makes sense when group-wide consistency and consolidated reporting matter most. A custom ERP pays off when your local operations are specific and that specificity is part of your competitive advantage. For many foreign-owned companies in Uzbekistan, the right answer is a hybrid.
How a custom system is built and when it is justified is covered in the main guide, custom ERP development in Uzbekistan. This article answers a narrower, practical question: which of the options to choose, and for which processes.
Start with the right question
The most common mistake is starting with vendor comparisons. Every system looks good in a demo. A better sequence starts elsewhere.
First, list the core processes of your local entity: sales, procurement, inventory, production, distribution, cash handling, statutory accounting, payroll and HR. Then ask one question about each: is this process essentially the same as in most companies, or is it specific to how you operate here?
Statutory accounting and tax reporting follow the same local rules for everyone. Distributor bonus schemes, return terms, pricing by sales agent or region and the way orders arrive through local channels are often unique to a particular business.
If you are still asking whether you need an ERP at all, start with the self-assessment in signs your business needs an ERP.
The options, assessed neutrally
1. A local platform (for example, 1C) with customisation
1C is widely used in Uzbekistan. It offers standard configurations for accounting, trade and inventory, which specialists then adapt to a company's requirements.
Also read Your Customer Calls Twice and Still Has to Spell Their Name: Connecting IP Telephony to ERP in UzbekistanStrengths:
- Accounting and tax reporting configurations are adapted to local requirements.
- Local accountants know it well, which simplifies hiring and onboarding.
- Specialists are widely available, so you are less dependent on a single contractor.
- Standard business logic is already in place.
Weaknesses:
- Specific processes require customisation, and heavy customisation makes upgrades harder.
- The interface is designed mainly for accounting users and can be less convenient for warehouse staff, sales agents or couriers.
- Integrations with bots, marketplaces or group systems are possible but usually require additional work.
2. Global ERP or packaged SaaS
This covers two different things. A global ERP is the system your group may already run at headquarters. Packaged SaaS is a ready-made cloud product for retail, inventory, CRM or small-scale ERP.
Strengths:
- A global ERP gives group-wide consistency, shared master data and consolidated reporting.
- Packaged SaaS launches fast and needs little upfront investment.
- Upgrades and hosting are the vendor's responsibility.
Weaknesses:
- Processes adapt to the product, not the other way round.
- Local statutory requirements often need a localisation add-on or a separate local accounting system.
- Global ERP rollouts to a small subsidiary can be long and heavy relative to the entity's size.
- Data sits with the vendor; check export options and data residency questions early.
3. Custom ERP
A custom ERP is built around your actual processes. It is developed in phases: the most painful module first, then the rest.
Strengths:
- The system follows your process instead of forcing workarounds.
- Required integrations — with 1C, group systems, payments or marketplaces — are designed in from the start.
- Code and database can belong to your company; this must be written into the contract.
- Role-specific interfaces: a mobile screen for field agents, a dashboard for local management and headquarters.
Weaknesses:
- Higher upfront cost and longer time to first launch.
- Outcomes depend heavily on the quality of the building team and documentation.
- Rebuilding statutory accounting from scratch rarely makes sense; integrating with an existing local system is usually wiser.
- It needs an ongoing budget for support and evolution.

Total cost of ownership: look beyond the first invoice
Comparing options by the initial price is a classic mistake. Estimate total cost of ownership (TCO) over at least 3–5 years, listing these components separately for each option:
- Initial cost — What to include: Licences, subscription or development, setup
- Customisation — What to include: Extra work for each specific requirement
- Localisation — What to include: Meeting local statutory and tax requirements
- Integrations — What to include: Payments, e-invoicing, bots, marketplaces, group systems
- Data migration — What to include: Cleaning and moving legacy spreadsheets and databases
- Training — What to include: Staff time and materials, in local languages where needed
- Infrastructure — What to include: Servers, cloud, backups
- Support — What to include: Bug fixes, local availability, response times
- Upgrades — What to include: Keeping up with platform and regulatory changes
- Hidden cost — What to include: Hours spent on manual re-keying and workarounds
The last line is the one most often missed. A cheap tool that forces two employees to spend an hour a day copying data between systems is not cheap. Convert that time into monthly working hours and add it to the table.
The factors that drive the price are covered in detail in what drives the cost of an ERP system.
Decision matrix
Tick the column that best describes your situation for each row. The option with the most ticks is the one to examine first.
- Core need is local statutory accounting and tax — 1C + customisation: ✔
- Group-wide consistency and consolidation are critical — Global ERP / SaaS: ✔
- Small entity, standard processes, fast start needed — Global ERP / SaaS: ✔
- Local processes are specific and a source of advantage — Custom ERP: ✔
- Many systems must be linked into one flow — Custom ERP: ✔
- Easy access to local specialists matters — 1C + customisation: ✔
- Full control over data and code is required — Custom ERP: ✔
- Initial budget is limited — 1C + customisation: ✔; Global ERP / SaaS: ✔
- Customisation costs are approaching a new build — Custom ERP: ✔
The matrix does not make the decision for you — it structures the discussion. If two columns end up tied, that usually points towards a hybrid design.
The hybrid approach: the most practical route for many companies
In many foreign-owned entities, no single system covers everything well. A practical architecture often looks like this:
- Statutory accounting and tax reporting stay in 1C. Local accountants work in a familiar environment, and reports follow local rules.
- Group reporting runs in the global ERP where one exists. Headquarters receives consolidated figures in its usual format.
- Operational processes run in a custom system. Sales, agents, inventory, branches and delivery follow your actual local logic.
- The systems exchange data through integrations. Documents, balances and payments synchronise automatically instead of being re-keyed.
The key condition is designing the integration from day one. Define which system is the master for each type of data: for example, product catalogue and stock in the operational system, the chart of accounts in 1C, group consolidation in the global ERP. Without that agreement, systems start contradicting each other.
A further benefit is management reporting. Local managers and headquarters can see a single view built from all sources; how to structure it is covered in management accounting for business owners.

If you are acquiring a business that already runs 1C
Foreign investors often face this choice after an acquisition. The local business keeps its books in 1C, while sales and inventory live in spreadsheets and messaging groups. There are three routes.
The first is to extend 1C. If the missing functions are close to standard configurations and a strong local specialist is available, this is the fastest path.
The second is to move operations into a separate system and integrate it with 1C. This fits when processes are specific, or when field staff need a proper mobile interface.
The third is to replace everything with the group's system. It is the riskiest route and rarely justified early on, because statutory accounting, e-invoicing and year-end closing carry real compliance responsibility.
A simple test helps: review the 1C changes requested over the past year. If most relate to operations rather than accounting, and each has been harder than the last, the second route deserves serious attention.
Selection checklist
Before you decide, confirm that:
- ☐ Core processes are listed and each is marked "standard" or "specific".
- ☐ A 3–5 year TCO is estimated for each option, including hidden costs.
- ☐ It is clear which system holds statutory accounting and tax reporting.
- ☐ Required integrations are listed: payments, e-invoicing, bots, marketplaces, group systems.
- ☐ Data export and migration options have been tested.
- ☐ Ownership of code, database and servers is defined in the contract.
- ☐ It is clear who supports the system locally and what happens if that person or team leaves.
- ☐ Local department heads and key users are involved in the choice.
- ☐ The first process to automate is agreed.
- ☐ Success measures are agreed: time saved, error rates, reporting speed.
What comes after the choice — analysis, configuration or development, testing and go-live — is laid out step by step in ERP implementation stages.
Four common selection mistakes
- "Headquarters uses it, so it will fit here." A system that works for the group may not fit local processes or local requirements.
- Looking only at the initial price. A cheap start can become expensive through customisation and manual work.
- Replacing a working system without a reason. If 1C handles statutory accounting well, removing it creates new risk.
- Leaving local users out. The people who use the system every day are the first to see its gaps.
Conclusion
A global ERP, 1C and a custom system are not rivals; they are tools for different jobs. Packaged and local platforms suit standard processes. A custom system pays off for specific processes that give you an edge. Most often, the best result comes from combining them deliberately. Start with a process map and a realistic TCO rather than with vendor demos, and the decision will rest on numbers rather than on marketing.
Frequently asked questions
Can we simply roll out our group's global ERP in Uzbekistan?
Often you can for group reporting and core finance, but local statutory accounting and tax reporting usually need either a localisation layer or a separate local system. Check early how the global system handles local requirements, who supports that part locally, and how data flows to your local accountants.
Why do so many local companies use 1C?
It is widely adopted, its configurations are adapted to local accounting and tax requirements, and local accountants and specialists know it well. For a foreign-owned entity this makes it a pragmatic choice for statutory books, even when operations or group reporting run elsewhere.
Is a custom ERP more expensive than the alternatives?
The upfront cost is usually higher. The fair comparison, however, is total cost of ownership over several years: customisation, licences or subscriptions, support, manual workarounds, integrations and upgrades. The result differs from company to company.
Where should the selection process start?
With a list of processes, not with vendor demos. Mark each core process as standard or specific to your business. Standard processes are candidates for packaged tools; specific ones for configuration, a custom module or a dedicated system.
Not sure which option fits your Uzbekistan entity?
We can walk through your processes together and give a neutral view of what belongs in 1C, a global or packaged system, and what needs a dedicated solution. The consultation is free.
Book a free consultation →